Saturday, December 31, 2011
Oh Boy!
After a long history of rejection, a plaintiff has prevailed in the Eleventh Circuit, in part because the Court did not again reject, as not probative of discrimination, that a white supervisor referred to him as "boy." We have previously posted about this case here.
Thursday, December 29, 2011
Recess!
The Hill has a good post on the potential of recess appointments to the NLRB. Unless the Senate acts to confirm the three pending nominations (it wont), the NLRB will only have 2 members at the end of the year. All 47 Republican Senators have sent a letter to the President asking him to reject recess appointments. Randy Johnson, the U.S. Chamber of Commerce’s senior vice president of labor, immigration and employee benefits notes, "I doubt the president would go forward because it would poison the well in the Senate.”
Monday, December 26, 2011
Shhhhhhhhh! Can't say that
Vaughan v. Woodforest Bank (5th Cir. 12/21/11) is an interesting case where a white branch manager was terminated by her white supervisor for "unsatisfactory performance" and comments allegedly made which had a racial component. The supervisor testified that “we cannot talk about race in the workplace” and that “if you talk about race in the workplace it’s racial discrimination.” She also elaborated on Vaughn’s “unsatisfactory conduct,” stating that there were three “racial” occurrences that formed the basis of her decision to fire Vaughn. The Court does a good job of deconstructing the comments and explaining why the employee has created a sufficient factual dispute to avoid summary judgment. To me though the unstated rationale is the Court's conclusion no minority employee would have been terminated for the reasons proffered.
Friday, December 23, 2011
NLRA Poster deadline postponed
Effective today, the NLRB has postponed the effective date for employers posting the required notification of employee rights under the National Labor Relations Act.
Wednesday, December 21, 2011
USCC v. NLRB
The U. S. Chamber of Commerce has sued the National Labor Relations Board to prevent implementation of the revised rules for conducting union elections. The complaint is here.
Saturday, December 17, 2011
Dangers of a nonfunctioning NLRB
Former NLRB Chairman William B. Gould, IV (1994-98) penned this op-ed piece in the New York Times concerning the effect a non-functioning NLRB on wokrers' rights. Gould among other things, urges the President to make it an election year issue.
Friday, December 16, 2011
Work stoppage may be unprotected
The D.C. Circuit in Fortuna Enterprises has refused to enforce a portion of an NLRB order finding the employer's suspension of employees who engaged in concerted activity by refusing to work until management addressed a complaint about discipline of another worker who engaged in organizing activities. The employees were hotel service staff who gathered in a company cafeteria and insisted upon meeting with management about the discipline. After being told to return to work or leave the premises several times during a 90 minute wait, the employees were suspended for insubordination. In finding a violation the Board concluded the employees had no procedure whereby they could present a group grievance, and that their gathering to complain was protected. The D.C. Circuit rejected the Board's finding on the employer's complaint procedure finding the employer's practice was to permit group complaints, and that the policy did not exclude such complaints. For these reasons the Court remanded the case to the NLRB for consideration in light o the ruling on review.
Thursday, December 15, 2011
President nominates two NLRB
The White House has announced the nominations of two Democrats for vacant positions on the NLRB. No word on whether they will get recess appointments. My bet is they wont be confirmed in advance of 2012 election.
Tuesday, December 13, 2011
UAW agenda
Will Canton Mississippi's Nissan plant be the next target in the UAW's drive to organize foreign automakers' plants in the U.S? This USA Today article suggests it will.
Saturday, December 10, 2011
Boeing settled
The much debated "controversial" Boeing unfair labor practice case concerning the relocation of work to South Carolina has been formally settled. While some suggest the result is due to "pressure", it is unlikely pressure from the right, as The Hill post suggests, contributed to the resolution. Acting General Counsel Solomon is closer to correct. The collective bargaining process worked. The company and the union bargained and as a result of the bargaining, the union requested the relocation charge be withdrawn. Thats the way collective bargaining should work. Unions are free to bargain away ULP's, particularly where there is no identifiable individual discriminatee.
Friday, December 9, 2011
Pretext due to employer not following its policies
I have long felt that employers who lack organization and sophistication in promulgating, maintaining, enforcing and revising written policies should consider having no written policies at all. A live and credible witness can explain why the decision adversely affecting a claimant is based on legitimate business related criteria. That can be enough for summary judgment. But when this explanation is in conflict with or contradicts employer's written policies, a material fact dispute likely exists. In Norris v. City of Millbrook, a federal district court in Alabama agrees. Money quote after the jump
Thursday, December 8, 2011
Transsexual protected against discrimination
The 11th Circuit has affirmed summary judgment in favor of a transexual employee who was terminated from her public sector job. The Defendant "testified that his decision to dismiss Glenn was based on his perception of Glenn as 'a man dressed as a woman and made up as a woman,' and [Defendant] admitted that his decision to fire Glenn was based on 'the sheer fact of the transition.' [Defendant's] testimony provides ample direct evidence to support the district court’s conclusion that [Defendant] acted on the basis of Glenn’s gender non-conformity. Although he case was brought as a constitutional equal protection claim the court acknowledged the underlying rationale would apply in a Title VII context.
Wednesday, December 7, 2011
A contrary view
CCH WorkDay Blog reviews a compendium of reports and studies challenging the notion that public sector employees are huge contributors to the country's economic problems.
Tuesday, December 6, 2011
Remember Andy Stern?
Former President of the SEIU and bad boy poster child (and pinata) of the anti union crowd, now works for Big Pharma. He's profiled in this piece at BeyondChron, which portrays him as a big fan of China's explosive state driven growth there, a blamer who notes the time of free markets is over, and by implication a tacit supporter of repressive working conditions. Go figure.
Friday, December 2, 2011
Unemployment drops to 8.6%
The Bureau of Labor Statistics (BLS) unemployment report released today indicates 120,000 jobs were added last month. The unemployment rate dropped also to 8.6%. BLS also revised upward the job growth in October by 72,000 jobs. This is the 4th month in a row the report as revised job growth upward over the initial estimate.
Thursday, December 1, 2011
Boeing settled?
The Seattle Times is reporting Boeing and the Machinists' union have reached a tentative agreement on a 4 year deal that will secure Washington state as the location of the company's fabrication of the 737MAX. The agreement purportedly includes a resolution of the unfair labor practice complaint issued over the relocation of part of the 787 fabrication to South Carolina. Previous posts here and here. The NLRB case has become a volatile political issue. Although NLRB Acting General Counsel Lafe Solomon must approve any settlement of the case, it is unlikely the NLRB will stand in the way of a settlement pushed by the IAM. Supporters of the Company's relocation of work to South Carolina should also be happy as the fabrication facility there will continue operations if the settlement is ratified by the union membership and approved by Solomon.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)