Showing posts sorted by date for query South Carolina. Sort by relevance Show all posts
Showing posts sorted by date for query South Carolina. Sort by relevance Show all posts
Friday, April 13, 2012
Rejected! Federal Judge nixes NLRB notice requirement
A federal district court in South Carolina has ruled the NLRB lacks the authority to promulgate the rule which requires employers to post a notice advising employees of their rights under the National Labor Relations Act. The opinion is here. The opinion is by District Judge David C. Norton who was appointed by by President George H. W. Bush. At first blush this seems to be a rather extraordinary reigning in of the NLRB's rule making authority.
Monday, January 2, 2012
It can get weirder
Seems some South Carolina Boeing employees have filed a "retaliation" charge against the Machinists' union because they used the NLRB process to bully Boeing into locating the 737 Max production line in Washington State. Through collective bargaining Boeing and the union reached a 4 year agreement which included assurances that the 737 Max line would be built in Washington, and also included a resolution of the 787 Dreamliner case which ensured that contested work relocation would remain in South Carolina. The employees were assisted by the National Right to Work Legal Defense Foundation. I wouldn't bet the farm on a complaint issuing on this charge.
Saturday, December 10, 2011
Boeing settled
The much debated "controversial" Boeing unfair labor practice case concerning the relocation of work to South Carolina has been formally settled. While some suggest the result is due to "pressure", it is unlikely pressure from the right, as The Hill post suggests, contributed to the resolution. Acting General Counsel Solomon is closer to correct. The collective bargaining process worked. The company and the union bargained and as a result of the bargaining, the union requested the relocation charge be withdrawn. Thats the way collective bargaining should work. Unions are free to bargain away ULP's, particularly where there is no identifiable individual discriminatee.
Thursday, December 1, 2011
Boeing settled?
The Seattle Times is reporting Boeing and the Machinists' union have reached a tentative agreement on a 4 year deal that will secure Washington state as the location of the company's fabrication of the 737MAX. The agreement purportedly includes a resolution of the unfair labor practice complaint issued over the relocation of part of the 787 fabrication to South Carolina. Previous posts here and here. The NLRB case has become a volatile political issue. Although NLRB Acting General Counsel Lafe Solomon must approve any settlement of the case, it is unlikely the NLRB will stand in the way of a settlement pushed by the IAM. Supporters of the Company's relocation of work to South Carolina should also be happy as the fabrication facility there will continue operations if the settlement is ratified by the union membership and approved by Solomon.
Thursday, September 29, 2011
A National Right to Work Law?
Senator Jim DeMint (R SC) has proposed passing a national right to work law. Texas Governor Rick Perry and former Massachusetts Governor Mitt Romney have said they both support it. This is, of course, a reaction to the Boeing case where the NLRB has issued a complaint against the company for building a second Dreamliner production line in South Carolina allegedly because the Machinists' union engaged in strikes in Washington State where the company had announced the expansion would be located. For a small government Party, the Republicans are awful quick to federalize certain issues which advance their agenda. Unions do the same thing (see EFCA). Under current law, states have the right to choose whether they permit an agency shop or not. An agency shop is one where a company and a union can agree that the employees are required to join the union. Federal law also says such arrangements cannot require actual membership in a union, only that an objecting worker pay partial dues attributable to the unions collective bargaining services. In the 22 right to work states, unions and employers are not permitted to require union membership, or any payment in lieu thereof, as a condition of employment.
Labels:
agency shop,
Boeing,
DeMint,
Dreamliner,
EFCA,
federal right to work law,
Perry,
Romney,
South Carolina
Friday, June 24, 2011
Boeing NLRB filing
The NLRB has filed its response to Boeing's motion to dismiss the complaint concerning the opening of a second Dreamliner production line in South Carolina.
Friday, June 10, 2011
Muddle, Meddle, Boing, Boeing
South Carolina's Attorney General has along with 14 other state's AG's filed a horribly muddled amicus brief in the Boeing case. While there are excellent arguments against the NLRB complaint, particularly the remedy sought requiring the work to be relocated, this brief only exposes the AG's utter lack of understanding of the National Labor Relations Act. Too much Chicken Little, too little understanding that the statute was designed to reign in managerial decision making. More explained in our previous posts.
Tuesday, May 24, 2011
GE, the same as Boeing?
Over the past few weeks I have been in a vigorous e-mail and phone debate with a fellow management lawyer concerning the meaning and effect of the issuance of a complaint in the Boeing case. Previous posts here. Contrary to many gloomy management predictions, I think Boeing is a fairly garden variety application of long established labor law. My friend believes it is a fundamental assault on employer free speech and employer right to determine facility location.
Now we have General Electric announcing the opening of a non-union locomotive factory in Texas. At the same time it is bargaining with union workers at at its existing locomotive factory in Pennsylvania. Assuming GE executives do not articulate an anti-union motivation for their actions, as is alleged that the Boeing executives did, this sets up an ideal scenario for testing the limits of the NLRB's interpretation of a Boeing style violation. Can the announcement of the location of a new facility in a right to work state during contract negotiations ever be viewed as an unfair labor practice? The correct conclusion is obvious, it cannot, without more, be a violation. Management has the right to determine where it locates facilities, as long as the decision is not tainted with anti-union motivation. The difference in Boeing is the NLRB believes the company's actions and statements establish an anti-union motivation for its decision and issued a complaint so that the issue will be tried before an administrative law judge. Boeing may still prevail, but it will have to show the relocation to South Carolina was motivated by lawful factors.
Now we have General Electric announcing the opening of a non-union locomotive factory in Texas. At the same time it is bargaining with union workers at at its existing locomotive factory in Pennsylvania. Assuming GE executives do not articulate an anti-union motivation for their actions, as is alleged that the Boeing executives did, this sets up an ideal scenario for testing the limits of the NLRB's interpretation of a Boeing style violation. Can the announcement of the location of a new facility in a right to work state during contract negotiations ever be viewed as an unfair labor practice? The correct conclusion is obvious, it cannot, without more, be a violation. Management has the right to determine where it locates facilities, as long as the decision is not tainted with anti-union motivation. The difference in Boeing is the NLRB believes the company's actions and statements establish an anti-union motivation for its decision and issued a complaint so that the issue will be tried before an administrative law judge. Boeing may still prevail, but it will have to show the relocation to South Carolina was motivated by lawful factors.
Thursday, May 5, 2011
Wrong, wrong, wrong, wrong, wrong, wrong, wrong wrong. You're wrong.
For a short opinion piece, rarely does any mainstream outfit get things so wrong. This from the WSJ. (If you are not a subscriber google search the title and you will find the article). The NLRB has issued a complaint accusing Boeing of committing an unfair labor practice when it moved a production line from Washington to South Carolina, and blamed the union's strike activity for the decision. Previous posts here. The issuance of a complaint means the NLRB believes there is sufficient evidence of a violation to warrant a trial on the issue before an administrative law judge. It is not a ruling, as the subtitle of the WSJ piece suggests. At the trial the employer will have the opportunity to prove its motivation was not based upon the union's protected right to strike, but rather was based on sound economic factors. Its really a pretty pedestrian legal theory applied to seemingly atrocious facts created by Boeing's own statements. This is law school 101. You can always file a complaint, its that pesky proof thats the hard part.
Essentially critics of the Boeing complaint are saying labor, and the federal agency protecting labor's statutory rights has no business second guessing an employer's decision to relocate a plant. That position, however, is contrary to well established labor law principles. An employer is not free to relocate a plant to avoid unionization, or because a union lawfully exercises a right (like striking). The article also implies an employer can simply move overseas. But such a move is also susceptible to a Boeing like Complaint, if it is motivated by anti-union sentiments.
The WSJ writer makes an absurd claim that the NLRB complaint is an assault on "the federal right to work law." A few senators, notably both senators from South Carolina, have introduced legislation prohibiting the NLRB or union contracts from pre-empting state right to work laws. There may be a legislative solution to this problem, but its not the proposed legislation discussed in the article. If a state passes a right to work law, there is nothing the NLRB or union can do to change the effect of the state law. The proposed legislation is totally redundant. Section 14(b) of the NLRA already prevents the NLRB or collective bargaining agreements from interfering with state right to work laws.
Finally, right to work has nothing to do with the issues addressed in the Boeing Complaint. Right to work laws guarantee an employee does not have to belong to, or pay a union in order to keep a job in a unionized facility. Such laws do not directly affect whether an employer can relocate or not.
Essentially critics of the Boeing complaint are saying labor, and the federal agency protecting labor's statutory rights has no business second guessing an employer's decision to relocate a plant. That position, however, is contrary to well established labor law principles. An employer is not free to relocate a plant to avoid unionization, or because a union lawfully exercises a right (like striking). The article also implies an employer can simply move overseas. But such a move is also susceptible to a Boeing like Complaint, if it is motivated by anti-union sentiments.
The WSJ writer makes an absurd claim that the NLRB complaint is an assault on "the federal right to work law." A few senators, notably both senators from South Carolina, have introduced legislation prohibiting the NLRB or union contracts from pre-empting state right to work laws. There may be a legislative solution to this problem, but its not the proposed legislation discussed in the article. If a state passes a right to work law, there is nothing the NLRB or union can do to change the effect of the state law. The proposed legislation is totally redundant. Section 14(b) of the NLRA already prevents the NLRB or collective bargaining agreements from interfering with state right to work laws.
Finally, right to work has nothing to do with the issues addressed in the Boeing Complaint. Right to work laws guarantee an employee does not have to belong to, or pay a union in order to keep a job in a unionized facility. Such laws do not directly affect whether an employer can relocate or not.
Thursday, April 21, 2011
South Carolina 787 Washington 0, or will there be a forfeit?
Remember Boeing's move to set up a second 787 Dreamliner fabrication line in non-union South Carolina? Previous posts here. And all Boeing's talk about the unions running them out of Everett, Washington? This from the NLRB:
NLRB Acting General Counsel Lafe Solomon today issued a complaint against the Boeing Company alleging that it violated federal labor law by deciding to transfer a second production line to a non-union facility in South Carolina for discriminatory reasons. . . .
To remedy the alleged unfair labor practices, the Acting General Counsel seeks an order that would require Boeing to maintain the second production line in Washington state.A trial before an administrative law judge is set for June 14. There are some very astute practitioners who sense this is another "great leap" from a pro-union NLRB, but I'm not so sure. This does not seem so much of a stretch given that Boeing initially announced the production would be in Everett, then switched it to South Carolina blaming the unions propensity to strike. A prima facie violation is made based upon the employer's statements. It is now incumbent on the employer to establish its move was based on legitimate motivation as in Dubuque Packing. Whether the Boeing case is momentous will depend on that proof, and the Board's evaluation of it.
Thursday, February 3, 2011
Speechless
The IAM has sued the Governor of South Carolina claiming anti-union remarks made by her were designed to intimidate workers into not joining a union. Interesting. The Attorney General claims the comments were made before the Governor took office, and in any event were protected by the First Amendment. This story harkens back to a previous post.
Friday, November 5, 2010
State anti-EFCA measures
Four states (Arizona, South Carolina, South Dakota and Utah) passed provisions requiring secret ballot elections to determine a union's majority status. First, it is extraordinarily unlikely the NLRB will abandon secret ballot elections, so any petition would be processed under the current, long-standing secret ballot election procedures used by the NLRB. As for voluntary recognition situations, under which employers and unions may by-pass the election process, the effect is less certain, but absent a major rethinking of federal preemption, I do not see how states can permissibly regulate the process of determining majority status by card check or other non-election evidence that a majority of the employees support unionization.
Tuesday, December 8, 2009
South Carolina 787 Washington 0, round 3
Boeing has announced it plans on duplicating all parts manufacturing near its new South Carolina 787 final assembly facility. Nothing will be uniquely manufactured in the Puget sound area. This will allow the South Carolina facility to operate completely independent of the Washington facilities and their strike prone Machinists union.
Monday, November 9, 2009
South Carolina 787 Washington 0
We've seen a lot of unspecific discussions about the Boeing/IAM negotiations central to the company's decision to locate its second 787 assembly line in South Carolina rather than in Washington state, but this latest article details how far apart the Machinists union and management were in contract negotiations.
Wednesday, November 4, 2009
South Carolina 787 Washington 0, part 2
The State.com has a good background piece on the South Carolina wooing of Boeing, including involvement of Senator Lindsey Graham.
Friday, October 30, 2009
Boeing move not isolated
Boeing's move to South Carolina, a bad thing for the Machinists' union, steps up the trend which began with the garment and broader textile industry leaving New York and New England and continues with the auto industry leaving Michigan. Business friendly sunbelt states have encouraged the trend with economic incentives and non-union friendly right to work laws. More and more heavy manufacturing will seek the competitive advantage of a union free workforce.
Thursday, October 29, 2009
South Carolina 787 Washington 0
Boeing has announced its decision to locate a second assembly line for its delayed 787 airplane in North Charleston, South Carolina. Doubtless the decision of its existing South Carolina facility to kick out the Machinists, as well as an 8 week strike at its Everett, Washington facility where the planes are currently assembled were factors in the decision.
Thursday, September 24, 2009
What hath Iqbal wrought
I have just read an extremely interesting article on pleading intentional discrimination after Iqbal v Ashcroft. It is a must read for Title VII litigators. The author is South Carolina law professor Joe Seiner. The article can be downloaded from Social Science Research Network. Professor Seiner lays out a persuasive argument for compliance with the heightened pleading requirement in cases alleging intentional discrimination post Iqbal. If the federal judiciary agrees with Professor Seiner's analysis both plaintiffs and defendants should benefit from clear guidance in this area. His suggested approach also diminishes the most troubling aspect of Iqbal, the plausibility component. Essentially Iqbal requires a judge to determine if the plaintiff's allegations are sufficiently compelling to be believable enough to warrant going forward. The troublesome aspect of this standard is it is not only subjective, but determined by a judge likely to have limited understanding of the realities of most workplaces.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)